Head-to-head comparison

Surfshark vs Proton VPN: Which VPN Is Better in 2026?

Surfshark logo Surfshark
vs
Proton VPN logo Proton VPN
Quick answer: Surfshark beats Proton VPN overall (4.8/5 vs 4.6/5). Surfshark is the cheaper option at $1.99/mo.

We compared Surfshark and Proton VPN across the factors that actually affect your purchase: price, real-world speed, privacy track record, server reach, and refund safety.

🏆 Overall winner: Surfshark

Advertising: This page contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you purchase through our links.

Metric SurfsharkWinner Proton VPN
Price $1.99/mo $3.99/mo
Rating 4.8/5 4.6/5
Speed 96/100 90/100
Privacy 94/100 98/100
Servers 4500+ 19000+
Money-back guarantee 30 days 30 days

Category by category

Rating

Surfshark leads on rating: 4.8/5 vs 4.6/5 for Proton VPN.

Speed

Surfshark leads on speed: 96/100 vs 90/100 for Proton VPN.

Privacy

Proton VPN leads on privacy: 98/100 vs 94/100 for Surfshark.

Price

Surfshark is cheaper at $1.99/mo vs $3.99/mo for Proton VPN on long-term plans. Renewal prices are higher for both.

Servers

Surfshark: 4500+ · Proton VPN: 19000+

Choose Surfshark if you want

  • Best value
  • Unlimited devices
  • Unlimited connections
  • Great streaming unlock
  • CleanWeb ad/malware filter

Choose Proton VPN if you want

  • Privacy-first
  • Open-source apps
  • Excellent audits
  • Secure Core

Our verdict

Surfshark is our overall pick in this matchup thanks to a stronger balance of speed, privacy, and value. Proton VPN still makes sense if its pricing or specific features fit your setup better.

Frequently asked questions

Is Surfshark better than Proton VPN?

Surfshark is our overall pick in this matchup thanks to a stronger balance of speed, privacy, and value. Proton VPN still makes sense if its pricing or specific features fit your setup better.

Which is cheaper, Surfshark or Proton VPN?

Surfshark is cheaper at $1.99/mo vs $3.99/mo for Proton VPN on long-term plans. Renewal prices are higher for both.

Which is faster, Surfshark or Proton VPN?

Surfshark leads on speed: 96/100 vs 90/100 for Proton VPN.

Do Surfshark and Proton VPN offer a money-back guarantee?

Yes. Surfshark offers 30 days and Proton VPN offers 30 days, so you can test either one risk-free.

Read the full reviews

More VPN comparisons